Mother’s Day in the Homestead Kitchen: 5 Old-Fashioned Recipes to Cook with Mom

Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that if you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I only recommend products I genuinely trust and believe will bring value to my readers. Also, some of the content was created with strategic use of AI tools. For more information, please visit the Privacy Policy page. Thank you for supporting my blog and helping me continue to provide valuable content.

The kitchen is a sacred space—especially on Mother’s Day. Maybe it’s the scent of warm vanilla and spring herbs in the air, or the quiet joy of working side by side, hands dusted in flour, hearts full of memory. In our homestead kitchen, Mother’s Day isn’t about polished silver or restaurant reservations. It’s about cozy, familiar flavors that remind us where we came from—and who we still have to thank.

These five old-fashioned recipes aren’t trendy or complicated. They’re nostalgic, humble, and made to be cooked with someone you love. Whether you whip up one or make all five throughout the day, they’re little invitations to linger in the kitchen just a bit longer.

1. Strawberries & Cream Dutch Baby with Lemon Balm Syrup

Puffy, golden, and garden-kissed.

A Dutch baby is magic in the oven—eggy batter rises into a soft-edged puff with crisp edges, begging for something fresh on top. I always turn to strawberries in early May, when they’re warm from the vine and need nothing more than a drizzle of something lovely. Enter: lemon balm syrup. It’s subtle and floral, like the morning light across your mother’s kitchen table. Serve this straight from the skillet, with cream or yogurt, and maybe a sprig of lemon balm for her plate.

Why you’ll love it:

• No flipping, no fuss—just mix and pour.
• Great use for backyard strawberries or market finds.
• Lemon balm adds a beautiful herbal twist.

2. Brown Butter Honey Skillet Cornbread

Golden edges, deep flavor, and Sunday memories baked in.

Cornbread might not seem like a celebration food—but in our house, it always has been. The crackle of the skillet, the scent of browned butter mingling with cornmeal… it’s the sound of someone coming home. This version leans just a little sweeter, with honey stirred in at the end. Serve it with butter, fresh jam, or tucked into a picnic basket if you’re heading to the porch or park with Mom.

Why you’ll love it:

• Brown butter adds irresistible richness.
• Bakes up with crisp, golden edges in cast iron.
• Perfect with soups, salads, or as a sweet brunch side.

3. Farmhouse Chicken Pot Pie with Fresh Thyme & Garden Veggies

Tender crust, cozy filling, and thyme-scented love.

Pot pie is a dish for unhurried afternoons. Making it together—chopping carrots, stirring roux, gently folding dough—is as much the point as eating it. This one’s packed with spring vegetables and laced with thyme, that comforting herb that feels like a hug from the garden. The crust is flaky and buttery, and the filling… well, let’s just say it makes everyone quiet for a minute when they take the first bite.

Why you’ll love it:

• Full of seasonal vegetables and fresh herbs.
• Scratch-made filling that’s rich but not heavy.
• Ideal for Sunday lunch or a late-day Mother’s Day dinner.

4. Lemon Lavender Pudding Cakes (in Mason Jars!)

Soft, citrusy, and just a little floral.

There’s something so special about dessert in a jar. These pudding cakes bake into themselves—cake on top, pudding on the bottom—and deliver that delicate lemon-lavender balance that feels like walking through a blooming kitchen garden. They’re elegant, but not fussy. Sweet, but never cloying. Wrap one in ribbon for Mom, or make a few extra to share with the ladies at church.

Why you’ll love it:

• Bakes right in Mason jars—cute, giftable, and practical.
• Light, custardy texture with bright lemon flavor.
• Lavender adds a gentle floral hint (not overpowering!).

5. Chicory Coffee Custard Pie

Silky, earthy, and deeply Southern.

This pie isn’t flashy—but it’s unforgettable. Chicory root has a roasted, almost chocolatey bitterness that anchors the silky custard filling. It’s the kind of dessert you serve in thin slices, with a spoonful of whipped cream and a story about your grandmother’s pantry. I serve it as a slow, late-afternoon treat—just as the sun fades and the kitchen grows quiet again.

Why you’ll love it:

• A beautiful old-world flavor, not too sweet.
• Custard texture that melts in your mouth.
• Perfect with afternoon coffee or after a hearty meal.

Closing Thoughts

Cooking together is more than nourishment—it’s remembrance. These old-fashioned recipes aren’t just meals; they’re memories in the making. So light a candle, tie on an apron, and step into the kitchen with your mom, your daughter, or a friend who feels like both. This Mother’s Day, let the love be homemade.

Be sure to subscribe to the newsletter or follow along on Pinterest so you don’t miss a bite!